Justice Secretary Aguirre Releases Official Statement Against the Privilege Speech of Sen. Hontiveros

7 mins read
The Secretary of the Department of Justice (DOJ) Secretary Vitaliano Aguirre II released an official statement in response to the privilege speech of Sen. Risa Hontiveros calling for his resignation as Secretary of the DOJ.

Sen. Hontiveros demanded the resignation of Justice Secretary Aguirre II for allegedly plotting to bring cases against the senator. The Akbayan senator who is closely connected with the Liberal Party took the floor of the Senate and made a privilege speech saying that a photograph or Aguirre, during Senate hearing proves that the DOJ secretary was plotting against her.

According to the accusations of Hontiveros, a photographer, whom she did not identify, inadvertently captured an exchange of text messages that Aguirre was having during the hearing.

SOJ Aguirre for his part released an official statement as his response to the accusations thrown at him by Sen. Hontiveros. According Sec. Aguirre he condemn such an act of Hontiveros for being unethical and for being unbecoming of a public servant.

Watch the Privilege Speech of Sen. Hontiveros:

Here’s the Complete Statement of DOJ Sec. Aguirre:

STATEMENT OF JUSTICE SECRETARY
VITALIANO N. AGUIRRE II
ON THE PRIVILEGE SPEECH OF
SENATOR RISA HONTIVEROS ON
SEPTEMBER 11, 2017


Beyond the issue of legality is the issue of decency. Anybody who uses
the fruits of an unconstitutional or an illegal act is bereft of
decency.

I condemn such an act for being unethical and for being
unbecoming of a public servant. That a public servant will conveniently
resort to the protective mantle of a privilege speech makes it more
despicable and diabolical.

Any self respecting member of the
media should condemn this dastardly act of a supposed brethren in the
profession. The media should not let the unscrupulous acts of a few
tainted ones destroy the nobility and the purity that is still present
in the majority of its ranks.

—Justice Secretary Vitaliano N. Aguirre II


I wish to protest to the Filipino people, to whom we all are
accountable, the apparent intrusion and the blatant disregard of my
Constitutional rights to the privacy of communication committed during
the hearing of the Committee on Public Order and Dangerous Drug on
September 5, 2017.

The right to privacy of communication is a
constitutionally guaranteed right under Article III of the 1987
Constitution which states that:

Section 3. (1) The privacy of
communication and correspondence shall be inviolable except upon lawful
order of the court, or when public safety or order requires otherwise,
as prescribed by law.

(2) Any evidence obtained in violation of
this or the preceding section shall be inadmissible for any purpose in
any proceeding.

Text messages are private communications. Any
unauthorized intrusion into such exchanges is illegal and betrays the
Constitution. 

I condemn to the highest degree this shameless violation of a citizen’s right to the privacy of communications.


I am saddened, enraged and more importantly, afraid of how our rights
to the privacy of our communication can easily be disregarded and
trampled upon. 

I am sad because the people who violated my right
to privacy of communication and the people who subsequently trumpeted
it, did so in the very hallowed halls of the Senate itself. 

I
have the highest regard and respect for the Senate as an institution.
For that reason, when I received an invitation to attend the hearing of
the Committee on Public Order and Dangerous Drugs as a resource person,
no matter how full my plate was at the Department of Justice, I found
and made the time to attend. 

As an invited resource person, I
trusted fully the Senate and the Honorable Committee to guarantee the
safety of my person and to ensure that all my rights will be respected
and will not be violated by anyone. 

I am saddened by the thought
that while I gave my time, cooperation and humble efforts to the Senate
during the hearing, unknown to me, I will be victimized and my rights
disregarded and my privacy intruded upon. 

Somebody, allegedly
from the media, if he or she is really from the media, not only violated
the express guarantees of our Constitution, but also committed a crime
when he or she targeted me.

Let us call a spade a spade. I was targeted. It was never inadvertent. 

Let him or her who claim that the act was not intentional present himself or herself to prove it.

The act of unauthorized prying into an exchange of private text
messages and the subsequent act of making it very public, also without
authority, is a flagrant violation of Republic Act no. 4200 or the
Anti-Wire Tapping Act.

The law prohibiting and penalizing wire tapping and violating the privacy of communications is very clear: 


Section 1. It shall be unlawful for any person, not being authorized by
all the parties to any private communication or spoken word, to tap any
wire or cable, or by using any other device or arrangement, to secretly
overhear, intercept, or record such communication or spoken word by
using a device commonly known as a dictaphone or dictagraph or
detectaphone or walkie-talkie or tape recorder, or however otherwise
described:

It shall also be unlawful for any person, be he a
participant or not in the act or acts penalized in the next preceding
sentence, to knowingly possess any tape record, wire record, disc
record, or any other such record, or copies thereof, of any
communication or spoken word secured either before or after the
effective date of this Act in the manner prohibited by this law; or to
replay the same for any other person or persons; or to communicate the
contents thereof, either verbally or in writing, or to furnish
transcriptions thereof, whether complete or partial, to any other
person: Provided, That the use of such record or any copies thereof as
evidence in any civil, criminal investigation or trial of offenses
mentioned in Sec. 3 hereof, shall not be covered by this prohibition.


Sec. 2. Any person who willfully or knowingly does or who shall aid,
permit, or cause to be done any of the acts declared to be unlawful in
the preceding Sec. or who violates the provisions of the following Sec.
or of any order issued thereunder, or aids, permits, or causes such
violation shall, upon conviction thereof, be punished by imprisonment
for not less than six months or more than six years and with the
accessory penalty of perpetual absolute disqualification from public
office if the offender be a public official at the time of the
commission of the offense, and, if the offender is an alien he shall be
subject to deportation proceedings. 

The person or persons
responsible for violating my right to privacy of communications during
that September 5, 2017 hearing also did not respect the Committee on
Public Order and Dangerous Drugs and the Senate as a whole. 

What
is disturbing and scary is what has been done before can be done again.
And when they do, they will always claim inadvertence but their acts
will always scream intentional. 

We should be scared. If they can do it to me, they can do it to anybody even to the Senators themselves. 

No secrets. No privacy. No sanctity. No respect. No peace of mind.

Any text or sms exchanges in our mobile phones, which are part of our
private communications, apparently are no longer private and safe!

The claim of inadvertence notwithstanding, any resource person invited by the Senate is now a potential victim. 

Everybody can now be victimized, anyone can now be a victim.
No one can feel safe because no one is safe not even our Senators.
Who will be next?


I caution everyone, be on your guard at all times. If in driving, we do
not drink and drive, in attending inquiries of our Congress, the lesson
learned is we do not talk and text. 

All that any person, with
an axe to grind against anyone, has to do is to claim that a member of
the media inadvertently took a picture of the text messages in the
screen of a targeted person’s mobile phone and precipitate its
unauthorized release to the public. 

As I have said everybody
can be targeted. If unpunished and not nipped at the bud, we will all be
contributing to the creation of a monster which may become too big to
slay later on. 

To the supposed member of the media who
evidently disregarded the privacy of my communications, if you do truly
exist, I say shame on you! 

In exchange for a news item for which you cannot and will not claim authorship and responsibility, you prostituted yourself.


Any self respecting member of the media should condemn this dastardly
act of a supposed brethren in the profession. The media should not let
the unscrupulous acts of a few tainted ones destroy the nobility and the
purity that is still present in the majority of its ranks. 


While the media should be a sentinel of the truth, it should not be a
perpetrator of a wrong or a violator of a person’s rights. 


Beyond the issue of legality is the issue of decency. Anybody who uses
the fruits of an unconstitutional or an illegal act is bereft of
decency. 

I condemn such an act for being unethical and for being
unbecoming of a public servant. That a public servant will conveniently
resort to the protective mantle of a privilege speech makes it more
despicable and diabolical. 

Nobody but nobody, should be
allowed to profit from committing an unconstitutional and an illegal
act, not even a Senator of the Republic. 

Any act or series of
acts that will emanate from such an unconstitutional and an illegal act
do not even deserve a scant regard and should be treated as
non-existent, and if invoked or raised by anybody, should be slain at
sight. 

As to the call for me to resign, let me say for the nth
time that for as long as I have the trust and for as long as I enjoy the
confidence of President Duterte who appointed me, I will continue
serving our people as the steward of your DOJ. 

You can call on me to resign, no one is stopping you, but only the President can accept my resignation. 


In closing, allow me to repeat this warning. If it could be done to me,
it could be done to anybody. Everyone can be targeted. No one is safe.
And that should really scare all of us.

—+++—

 Source: Son of Sec. Aguirre (Aris Aguirre)

Ed Umbao

Founder of PhilNews.xyz | co-Founder of PhilNews.ph

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Latest from Blog